On a whim, I signed up last week for an ESPN public fantasy baseball league. It was quite a strange experience, because only one other manager showed up for the live draft. The other eight elected for auto-pick.
I had the #6 pick overall, and the other live manager had #10. My picks and reasoning:
1. Robinson Cano (2b) - the first five picks were Pujols, Hanley Ramirez, Crawford, Longoria, and Braun. I debated between Cano and Miguel Cabrera, but went with Cano because of positional scarcity and the potent Yankees lineup.
2. Ryan Zimmerman (3b) - I could have taken Felix Hernandez or Josh Hamilton instead. I don't like to take pitchers before round 5 if possible, and I think Hamilton won't be as good this year as last year.
3. Joe Mauer (c) - This might have been a reach, but I liked him better than Jon Lester, Adam Dunn, or Dustin Pedroia, who were the next picks.
4. Jose Reyes (ss) - In the past, I've tended to neglect speed, or relied on some semi-fast players, hoping for an overall decent total of stolen bases. Let's see if this results in something different.
5. Justin Verlander (sp) - I gave in one round earlier than I would've liked, but top starting pitchers were gone. Verlander's been good for a number of years, and one of these years, he's going to put everything together. Maybe.
6. Andre Ethier (of) - I needed some outfielders . . . .
7. Jered Weaver (sp) - He led the AL in Ks last year. Hopefully it wasn't a fluke.
8. Paul Konerko (1b) - He's older of a player than I'd like, but first basemen seem to age somewhat better, and he's been pretty consistent.
9. Neftali Feliz (rp) - I think closers are vastly overrated, but it was time to pick one up.
10. Max Scherzer (sp) - I *really* like Scherzer. Last year, he got off to a bad start, got sent down to Triple-A, and worked out some mechanical flaw. When he returned, he was lights out.
11. Carlos Quentin (of) - Kind of a risky pick, but some potential reward there.
12. Gordon Beckham (mi) - I hope last year was a (bad) fluke.
13. Adam Jones (of) - Ditto.
14. JJ Putz (rp) - More saves please.
15. Jeremy Hellickson (sp) - I like gambling on young pitchers, and I think he could potentially be the best pitcher on the Rays. It should be either him or Price.
16. Brandon Morrow (sp) - Cal grad, awesome K/9 ratio, and not a lot of innings on his arm last year.
17. Drew Storen (rp) - Relatively low risk closer.
18. Mitch Moreland (ci) - I needed another corner infielder, and the remaining names weren't that appealing. Playing in Texas has got to count for something.
19. Carlos Beltran (of) - Another risk/reward pick.
20. Manny Ramirez (of) - Um, yeah, another risk/reward pick. Well, he's pretty awesome when he plays . . . .
21. Leo Nunez (rp) - Closer.
22. Ryan Raburn (of) - He was more valuable last year when he qualified at second base, but he's got some pop.
23. Hong-Chih Kuo (rp) - Pretty awesome rate stats. But I ended up cutting him after the draft to pick up Gio Gonzalez.
24. Peter Bourjos (of) - My hometown pick, and some cheap speed. We'll see if he's worth playing.
25. Ryan Madson (rp) - Fill-in closer, might still keep him after Lidge returns.